Upon graduating from Messiah, she taught piano lessons and directed the Indian Creek Church of the Brethren (COB) Choir in Harleysville, PA, as well as organized missions trips for GOGF Ministries in Lansdale, PA.

In 2008, Natasha put her musical endeavors and involvement with GOGF on hold to attend Cornell Law School, where she received her Juris Doctorate with a concentration in trial advocacy in 2011. She currently is an associate attorney with the Law Office of Maryann Q. Modesti, P.C., in Blue Bell, PA, where she practices family law in the surrounding counties (Philadelphia, Montgomery, Bucks, Chester, Delaware, Lehigh, and Berks).

After law school, Natasha continued to direct the Indian Creek COB Choir. In the fall of 2023, she revived the Montco Bible Fellowship Choir, which had been lying dormant for over 10 years after losing their director. For Christmas 2023, Natasha merged both choirs for a Christmas Concert, and from then on has led both choirs as one joint choir. She incorporated the joint choir in August 2025 as a non-profit, community choir under the name “Hearts of Worship Choir.” Since incorporation, the choir has expanded to include members and musicians from other churches, and we have seen God’s hand at work to broaden the outreach of our ministry.